We find solutions to save money, not just immediately try to sell you a new roof !!!
Serving the Ohio & Kentucky River Valley Area
.png/:/rs=h:320,cg:true,m/qt=q:100/ll)
The Ultimate Roof Insurance Guide in 2025
Does Insurance Cover Roof Repair?
Introduction
Imagine waking up to the sound of dripping water and realizing your roof has sprung a leak. Panic sets in, and your first thought is: "Will my homeowners insurance cover this?" It's a question thousands of homeowners face every year, especially after storms, hail damage, or unexpected accidents.
The truth is, insurance coverage for roof repairs isn’t always straightforward. It depends on your policy, the cause of the damage, and even the age of your roof. If you're not careful, you could end up paying for repairs out of pocket—even if you assumed insurance had you covered.
So, let’s break it down. When does homeowners insurance cover roof repair? When does it not? And how do you file a claim successfully?
Richter Roofing Insurance Claim Assistance Available on our
Ohio Servicing Areas (Insurance Claim Assistance Available):
Franklin Furnace, OH • Hillsboro, OH • Ironton, OH • Lucasville, OH • Manchester, OH • New Boston, OH • Peebles, OH • Portsmouth, OH • Rarden, OH • West Union, OH • Wheelersburg, OH
Kentucky Servicing Areas (Insurance Claim Assistance Available):
Ashland, KY • Greenup, KY • Maysville, KY • Raceland, KY • Russell, KY • South Shore, KY • Westwood, KY
When Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Roof Repairs?
In most cases, homeowners insurance will cover roof repairs if the damage is sudden and accidental—meaning it wasn’t something that could have been prevented. Here are some examples of covered damage:
✅ Storm damage – High winds, hail, and heavy rain that cause leaks or structural issues.
✅ Falling objects – Trees, branches, or debris causing damage.
✅ Fire or smoke damage – Includes damage from lightning strikes.
✅ Vandalism – If someone intentionally damages your roof.
✅ Weight of snow or ice – Roof collapse or structural damage due to excessive weight.
If your roof is newer and in good condition, you have a better chance of full coverage. But if your roof is over 20 years old, many insurers will only cover a portion of the repair costs—or deny the claim entirely.
When Roof Repairs Are NOT Covered by Insurance
Here’s where things get tricky. Just because your roof is damaged doesn’t mean your insurer will pay for it. In fact, there are several situations where they’ll outright deny a claim:
🚫 Normal wear and tear – Insurance doesn’t cover aging shingles, leaks due to an old roof, or general deterioration.
🚫 Lack of maintenance – If your roof has pre-existing issues (like missing shingles you ignored), your insurer may claim “neglect” and deny coverage.
🚫 Poor installation or workmanship – If your original roofer did a bad job, insurance won’t cover repairs due to faulty work.
🚫 Damage from floods or earthquakes – Standard policies don’t cover these—you’d need separate coverage.
🚫 Pre-existing damage – If the issue was there before you got the policy, you’re out of luck.
💡 Pro Tip: Many policies have fine print about exclusions—it’s worth reviewing your coverage now before you actually need it.
Roofing Regulations and Insurance Policies
Navigating roofing regulations and insurance policies can be complex, especially when operating in multiple states like Ohio and Kentucky. Here's a breakdown of key differences and similarities between these two states:
1. Building Codes and Permits:
- Ohio: The state enforces mandatory statewide building codes. Roofing projects must comply with the Ohio Building Code, which is based on the 2015 International Building Code (IBC). Local jurisdictions are responsible for enforcement, and while they must adhere to state codes, they may have additional local requirements. Therefore, it's essential to consult local authorities before commencing any roofing work.
- Kentucky: Similarly, Kentucky has mandatory statewide building codes. The Kentucky Building Code is also based on the 2015 IBC. However, Kentucky operates under a "mini/maxi" code system, meaning local governments cannot enforce building codes that are more or less stringent than the state code for single-family dwellings, two-family dwellings, and townhouses. This uniformity aims to ensure consistency across the state.
2. Roofing Contractor Licensing:
- Ohio: Roofing contractors are required to register with the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board. This process includes passing exams and providing proof of insurance. Additionally, contractors must maintain liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage.
- Kentucky: The state does not mandate a specific license for roofing contractors. However, local jurisdictions may have their own licensing or registration requirements. It's crucial to check with local authorities to ensure compliance.
3. Insurance Coverage and Matching Regulations:
- Ohio: The Ohio Administrative Code 3901-1-54 addresses the issue of "matching" in insurance claims. Insurers are required to replace damaged property with materials of "like kind and quality" to ensure a "reasonably comparable appearance." This means if a section of your roof is damaged, the replacement materials should match the existing roof as closely as possible. If an exact match isn't feasible, the insurer may be obligated to replace additional sections to achieve uniformity.
- Kentucky: There is no specific state law mandating that insurers match replacement materials with existing ones. Insurance policies may vary, and unless a policy explicitly requires matching, insurers might only be obligated to repair or replace the damaged section, even if the new materials don't match the undamaged portions. This approach can lead to aesthetic inconsistencies, so it's advisable for homeowners to review their policies carefully and discuss matching concerns with their insurers.
4. Local Variations:
- Ohio: While the state enforces a uniform building code, local municipalities handle enforcement and may have additional requirements or amendments. It's essential to consult local building departments to understand any specific regulations or permit requirements in your area.
- Kentucky: Despite the statewide code, enforcement can vary. Some counties may not require building permits or inspections for residential construction. For instance, certain areas might not mandate residential building inspections, focusing only on utility permits and inspections. Always verify with local authorities to ensure compliance.
Operating in both Ohio and Kentucky requires a thorough understanding of each state's regulations and local requirements. While both states have adopted the 2015 IBC as their building code foundation, differences exist in enforcement, contractor licensing, and insurance practices. To ensure compliance and protect your business and clients:
- Consult Local Authorities: Always check with local building departments for specific regulations, permit requirements, and any amendments to the state code.
- Review Insurance Policies: Understand the nuances of insurance coverage in each state, especially concerning material matching and claim procedures.
- Stay Informed: Building codes and regulations can change. Regularly update your knowledge and adjust your business practices accordingly.
How to File a Roof Repair Insurance Claim (Step-by-Step)
If you believe your roof repair is covered by insurance, follow these six steps to increase your chances of approval:
1. Document the Damage Immediately
- Take clear photos and videos from multiple angles.
- If possible, use before-and-after photos to prove the damage is new.
2. Review Your Homeowners Insurance Policy
- Look for specific coverage on wind, hail, storm damage, and roof repairs.
- Check deductible amounts—you may need to cover some costs out of pocket.
3. Contact Your Insurance Company ASAP
- Report the damage immediately. Some policies have a time limit for claims.
- Ask for a claim number and adjuster assignment.
4. Schedule a Professional Roof Inspection
- Your insurer will send an adjuster, but it’s smart to have your own roofer inspect the damage.
- A professional roofer can provide a detailed report supporting your claim.
5. Get Multiple Repair Estimates
- Insurance companies often try to lowball repair costs—having quotes from contractors gives you leverage.
- Choose a licensed and insured roofer (avoid storm chasers who show up after disasters).
6. Negotiate or Appeal if Necessary
- If the insurer offers less than expected, you can negotiate.
- If they deny your claim, you can file an appeal—especially if you have solid evidence.
Pro Tips to Get Your Roof Repair Approved by Insurance
Want to increase your chances of approval? Here’s what experienced homeowners do:
✔️ Keep a record of maintenance – Show proof of regular inspections and repairs.
✔️ Use a licensed roofer for inspections – Their report holds more weight.
✔️ Be wary of "storm chasers" – Scammers often prey on homeowners after big storms.
✔️ Get everything in writing – Verbal promises from insurance reps won’t hold up later.
✔️ If denied, ask why – Sometimes an appeal with better documentation can overturn a decision.
Should You Repair or Replace? Understanding Insurance Payout
Not all roof damage leads to a simple repair. Sometimes, insurance companies determine that replacing the entire roof is more cost-effective.
Here’s how they decide:
🟢 Actual Cash Value (ACV) – Insurer covers the roof’s depreciated value. Older roofs = lower payouts.
🟢 Replacement Cost Value (RCV) – Pays for a new roof without factoring in depreciation. Only available if you have full replacement coverage.
🟢 Repair vs. Replace – If the damage is small, they’ll usually approve a repair. If over 25-30% of the roof is affected, they might cover a full replacement.
💡 Pro Tip: If your policy is ACV-based, your payout could be significantly lower than expected.
Conclusion
So, does insurance cover roof repair? The answer is yes—sometimes. If your roof was damaged by a storm, fire, or vandalism, there’s a good chance you’ll be covered. But if it’s due to age, neglect, or poor workmanship, you’re on your own.
That’s why regular maintenance, inspections, and choosing a good roofer matter. If you ever need help navigating a claim or assessing your roof damage, Cincinnati Roofing Solutions is here to help!
💬 Need expert advice? Contact us today for a free inspection and insurance consultation!